Case 2 :
*Mr. and Mrs. Mahender Singh, Haryana.
Himself not well, mild vain effected, due to cases.
Daughter-in-law asking house and maintenance in DV Law (Protection of women from Domestic Violence LAW, effective from Oct 2006).
*Marriage of son happened in 2000. Daughter-in-Laws father was district attorney
(Govt. Lawyer), later promoted to Joint director in prosecution. Son was lawyer.
Son and his wife were given a place to stay above the school, school had 5, 6
teachers and was running good. Daughter was MPhil, Bed, she was running the
school, daughter-in-law joined in the running. The daughter-in-Law and married
daughter had difference of opinion about school control. School owned 50% by
Son and 50% by daughter. Daughter-in-law called her brother, he threatened.
*Daughter-in-law went to her parents home, they file dowry (498a) complaint against
5 persons including daughter and her husband. And filed attempt to murder by
burning under 307 IPC.
*With great troubles they got anticipatory bail in session court, and later regular bail
in lower court. Lost lots of health and money.
Son filed for divorce and child custody.
*False case 307(attempt to murder by burning), 498a were acquittal happened not
even compromise in the cases.
*After all this, sons wife decides to come back. She stayed for less then 2 months,
and left immediately when cancer was diagnosed to the son. Took grandson by
force.
*For 2 years tried hard to save sons life, lots of money also spent. Daughter-in-law
never visited .
*As a last wish he wanted to meet his son, but they refused. We called them to bring
son to do last rites of father (2007), waited but they did not come.
On 12th Day of death, they came and started asking for House, money etc.
*Filed DV Law (Protection of women from domestic Violence Law, effective from
Oct 2006), asking for living in house (that can be followed by asking to remove men
from the house), 20,000 per month maintenance from retired father-in-law in teaching
job, etc. She herself is earning as teacher.
*After getting notice in DV LAW, within 3 days, on first date maintenance of Rs 1,000
asked to be given to daughter-in-law from father-in-law. They are paying this money.
*Goods were deposited at police station, list signed by daughter-in-laws father.
Still they filed again case for goods; leading to harassment .The document was
reported by SSP and IG police.
Questions : Should the new DV Law( Domestic violence LAw ) allow maintenance,
and money for mental trouble allegations, from a finantialy weaker party ( say old
persons ) to a financially stronger party ( working Daughter-in-law ) .
* If a old couple allowed the sons wife to live for say less then 2 months to stay in their house , should the Law force the old couple to let the daughter-in-law live in their house and through the old man out of the house, on roads .
* Should the new radical feminists Laws be made in such a way that distroys
money , health , and jobs of men and their families, by making them run around in courts againsts anti men, barbaric wrong Laws.
Details available on request .
( Some names have been changed )
